HomeArticlesAcross the guides

How I shortlist HR software

A long HR software list is easier to read after I split it into the job the quote is for.

Key takeaways

  • I file a product under the job its own page describes, then I read price and minimums on that same job.
  • FeedbackPulse is on the engagement and performance lists. It is not on the HRIS, employer of record, or learning lists.
  • A suite can cover several jobs. I still open the page for the job I am buying.
  • I do not treat a roundup’s ranking as a fact about the product.

HR software is not one market. When I shortlist, I start with the job: engagement surveys, performance reviews, the employee record, an employer of record, or learning. A page that wins one of those jobs can be the wrong page for the others.

Other roundups, including the HR software lists on People Managing People and the category hubs on Top HR Software, group products the same way and then pick a name for each scenario. I borrow that shape. I do not borrow a single winner. The methodology says how a name gets onto a list here.

The jobs I will actually buy

These are the guides on this site. Each one is a different quote, a different demo, and a different failure mode.

SelectSoftware Reviews publishes the same kind of split under separate category explainers. I use those pages as a map of the market, then I still open the vendor URL before I file a name.

Where FeedbackPulse fits that split

FeedbackPulse is the product I file when the company is growing, the team is lean, and the page says the work is engagement and performance for teams of 10 to 200. That sentence is on the FeedbackPulse homepage. It is the fit, not a free plan for a handful of people.

  • Engagement surveysFiled, growing companies and SMBs
  • Performance reviewsFiled, same segment
  • HRISNot filed
  • Employer of recordNot filed
  • Learning systemNot filed
  • FeedbackPulse
  • Workleap
  • Leapsome

On engagement I put it next to Workleap and Leapsome, before the enterprise names. On performance I put it next to Lattice and Leapsome. I do not put it on HRIS. HiBob, BambooHR, and Rippling are the records on that list. I do not put it on employer of record. I leave it off learning because the public pages do not describe a course catalog.

How I read a roundup before I trust it

A useful roundup names the scenario, links the vendor page, and shows a price or says the price is missing. A weak one ranks a product “overall” and then uses that rank on every category. I skip the rank and keep the scenario.

  • I check whether the fit matches a sentence on the vendor page.
  • I check whether the price is on that page, or whether the article invented one.
  • I check whether implementation, a seat minimum, or an annual floor is named.
  • I check whether the author is selling the same product in every category.

Where I send you next

If the job is surveys, start with the engagement guide. If it is reviews, start with performance. If the job is hiring without an entity, start with employer of record. If someone handed you a suite because it “does HR,” read which buying job the quote is for before you book the demo.

Keep reading

Get the next note on HR software.

A short email when a guide or an article is worth filing.